Last updated:
Disclosure: This article contains affiliate links. If you buy through our links, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. All opinions are our own. Learn more.
Pros & Cons
What We Like
- Recycler mulching deck is strong when grass is kept on a normal mowing schedule
- Personal Pace removes the speed-matching effort
- SmartStow vertical storage saves real garage space
- Current-production Toro platform with good parts and manual support
Watch Out For
- Steel deck is heavier than aluminum competitors
- 21-22" cut is standard, not class-leading
- 150cc engine has less margin in tall wet growth than premium gas mowers
Best For
The classic 1/4 to 1/2 acre suburban lawn where you want a great mulcher and don't need a 30-inch deck.
The Owner-Style Take
Opinion
My read: Toro Recycler 22" SmartStow Self-Propelled Mower is not a universal recommendation. It earns its place when the use case is narrow and real: The classic 1/4 to 1/2 acre suburban lawn where you want a great mulcher and don't need a 30-inch deck.
The reason to keep it on the shortlist is Recycler mulching deck is strong when grass is kept on a normal mowing schedule. The reason to slow down before buying is steel deck is heavier than aluminum competitors. I would not treat the star rating as the decision; I would treat the yard, storage, maintenance tolerance, and five-year cost as the decision.
If you are deciding between this and Honda HRX217VKA 21" Variable-Speed Self-Propelled Mower, start with the failure mode you are trying to avoid. Pick Toro Recycler 22" SmartStow Self-Propelled Mower when the notes below describe your lawn more closely; pick Honda HRX217VKA 21" Variable-Speed Self-Propelled Mower when its compromises sound easier to live with.
Pick It Over
- Pick Toro Recycler 22" SmartStow Self-Propelled Mower over Honda HRX217VKA 21" Variable-Speed Self-Propelled Mower when its fit matches your yard better than the higher-rated alternative.
- Pick Toro Recycler 22" SmartStow Self-Propelled Mower over Craftsman M220 21" Self-Propelled Mower when rear-wheel traction, Personal Pace feel, and long-term mower familiarity matter more than the cheapest flat-yard gas option.
- Pick Toro Recycler 22" SmartStow Self-Propelled Mower over Toro TimeMaster 30" Personal Pace Self-Propelled Mower when its fit matches your yard better than the higher-rated alternative.
Skip If
- - You have less than 1/8 acre of simple flat turf; a lighter push mower may be cheaper and easier to store.
- - Steel deck is heavier than aluminum competitors
- - 21-22" cut is standard, not class-leading
Five-Year Cost
Estimated five-year cash outlay: $700-$1,075. That includes the current street-price range plus oil, spark plugs, air filters, blades, belts, and fuel-system care; it does not assume a paid repair shop unless the category commonly forces one.
Toro Recycler 22" SmartStow Self-Propelled Mower: Editorial Assessment
This is the self-propelled mower I would point most normal suburban owners to before the premium stuff. The Recycler 21465 is not romantic. It is just the right size, the right price class, and the right level of complexity for a 1/4- to 1/2-acre lawn. Personal Pace rear-wheel drive is the key feature: it avoids the fixed-speed lurch of cheaper mowers and keeps traction better than front-wheel-drive units when the bag gets heavy.
The SmartStow hinge is not a gimmick if your garage is already crowded. A mower that can stand vertically is easier to keep than a premium mower that blocks bikes, trash bins, and snow shovels all year. The 150cc Briggs EXi is not as muscular as the Honda GCV200 or TimeMaster's 223cc engine, so I would not oversell it for wet spring growth or tall neglected turf. But extension mowing guidance is clear that good mowing is mostly about sharp blades, the one-third rule, and regular cadence. For that reality, the Recycler is plenty.
Pick it over the Craftsman M220 if you can afford the step up from front-wheel drive. Pick it over the Honda if you want a current-production gas mower with easier retail support. Skip it if your actual problem is mowing-time reduction on a big open lot.
Purchase Options
Similar Products
ToolPickHomeowners with 1/4 to 3/4 acre lots, hills, thick turf, or heavy leaf mulching who can verify recall status and have local Honda service support.
ToolHomeowners with small, flat lawns who find it well below Toro Recycler pricing and do not need rear-wheel-drive traction.
ToolPickHomeowners with 1/2 to 1 acre of open, mostly flat turf who want to cut mowing time but do not want a rider or zero-turn.